#30 Australia's hidden surveillance machine, the Code of Behaviour - with Zaki Haidari and Dr Anthea Vogl

Episode 30 June 16, 2022 00:51:11
#30 Australia's hidden surveillance machine, the Code of Behaviour - with Zaki Haidari and Dr Anthea Vogl
Rules to Reality: how regulation shapes, or fails to shape, our daily lives
#30 Australia's hidden surveillance machine, the Code of Behaviour - with Zaki Haidari and Dr Anthea Vogl

Jun 16 2022 | 00:51:11


Show Notes

Today I am talking with Zaki Haidari and Dr Anthea Vogl on Australia’s immigration system and the use of the “Code of Behaviour”.

Zaki is a 2020 Australian Human Rights Commission Human Rights Hero, an Ambassador for the Refugee Advice and Casework Service, and works at Amnesty International as a Refugee Rights Campaigner. Zaki himself is a refugee, having fled Afghanistan after being targeted to be killed by the Taliban and has survived a terrifying boat journey to Australia in 2012. Despite this and a range of social, legal and financial obstacles, he has thrived, learning English and has become a well-known and respected human rights advocate speaking about the cruelty in Australia’s refugee system.

Anthea is senior lecturer at the UTS Faculty of law. Her work takes a critical and interdisciplinary approach to the regulation of migrants and on-citizens, with lots of this content falling within refugee, migration, and administrative law and theory. She is one of few Australians to highlight the issues in the Code of Behaviour.

As I mentioned, today we discuss the Code of Behaviour. In 2013, then Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Scott Morrison, introduced a Code of Behaviour for asylum seekers released from detention. In order to be released from detention, asylum seekers must sign the code. The Code contains obligations on asylum seekers that both duplicate, and exceed the criminal law. These include requiring people to not make sexual contact with another person without their consent, to obey existing Australian laws, and undefined content, like to not engage in any, and I quote “anti-social or disruptive activities that are inconsiderate, disrespectful or threaten the peaceful enjoyment of other members of the community”….you know, like possibly advocating for your human rights. If you are found by the Department to have breached any of these conditions, you can have your welfare taken, or be put back in on-shore or off-shore detention.

All of these provisions are part of what’s called refugee and administrative law. They have all of the flavour and consequences of criminal law, but without any of the checks and balances before courts. Zaki has lived this and Anthea has researched this. Anthea’s research reveals all of these features in more depth, but also, that that non-governmental organisations are being co-opted into acting as police and surveillance officers of refugees and migrants.

We enter a new Albanese government with new Ministers for Immigration and for Home Affairs. This Code was written with a Ministry pencil, and can be erased at a Ministers discretion – Parliament was never involved. Consider writing to your local MP and the Ministers for Immigration and Home Affairs to have this inhumane code removed immediately.

Other Episodes

Episode 12

November 24, 2021 00:35:04
Episode Cover

#12 Full decriminalisation so that no sex worker is left behind - with Dylan O'Hara (Vixen Collective)

Today I am speaking to Dylan from Vixen Collective, Victoria’s peer only sex work organisation, as recognised by Scarlet Alliance, Australian Sex Worker Association. Vixen Collective promote the cultural, legal, human, occupational and civil rights of sex workers. Most recently you might have heard from them during their Victorian campaign to fully decriminalise sex work. The conversation today was illuminating. There are few areas where regulation does a more damaging and discriminatory job than sex work in Victoria. The laws do not work, and need to be repealed and replaced with a fully-decriminalised approach to regulating sex-work. Dylan steps us through these changes, explaining why full decriminalisation is so important, but also, they help reframe some of the assumptions that underpin debates. What came through clearly is that we have got to get our discriminatory laws and attitudes out of their way, because sex workers are the experts in their industry and experience – they know what to do. I think you’ll learn a lot from this instalment. Enjoy. Timestamps: Why regulation matters to the sex work community (2:00) An update on the Sex Work Decriminalisation Bill 2021 before Parliament (8:00) Explaining what sex work decriminalisation is (12:00) The steps beyond decriminalisation (16:30) Stigma and discrimination as ongoing barriers to full citizenship (22:00) How we can reframe debates about sex work to focus on human rights (27:45) What listeners can do (33:00) Show notes: Learn more about Vixen Collective’s policy asks from their No Sex Worker Left Behind campaign: https://www.vixencollective.org/campaigns. Check out this briefing paper from Scarlett Alliance: https://scarletalliance.org.au/library/briefing_paper_full_decrim You can follow Vixen Collective on Twitter: https://twitter.com/VixenCollective Five things you can do: 1) Find your MP Find your local MP: https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/about/electorates 2) Give them a call Call them to let them know you want ...


Episode 10

November 10, 2021 00:52:09
Episode Cover

#10 Getting sophisticated about sanctions and supporting justice that heals - with Emeritus Professor John Braithwaite

Today I speak with Emeritus Professor John Braithwaite from the Australian National University's School of Regulation and Governance (RegNet). In 1992 John and Ian Ayres wrote a book that would change how people understand regulation. It was called Responsive regulation: Transcending the deregulation debate. A simple google of Google Scholar finds that it has been cited over 5700 times! The theory has been developed and applied in too many contexts to list. If that wasn't enough, John has also been at the forefront of restorative justice research and advocacy for the last 30 years. This doesn't do justice to his expertise, so you will just have to do your own research. Time-stamps:  Why regulation matters to John (2:00) What is responsive regulation (12:30) The risks of capture and corruption for regulators (18:00) The role of civil society to prevent capture and corruption of regulators (20:00) What is restorative justice (25:00) How the law steals your conflicts (28:00) How does restorative justice deal with individual accountability (33:45) How does John approach the question of freedom and domination in restorative and responsive regulation (44:00) The one thing John wants you to do (49:00) Show notes The pyramid of sanctions!: http://johnbraithwaite.com/responsive-regulation/pyramid-of-supports-sanctions/ ...


Episode 5

May 31, 2022 00:57:24
Episode Cover

[Repeat] #5 Law, regulation and the need to respect different ways of knowing and being - with Hon Prof Kevin Bell AM QC

  Professor the Honourable Kevin Bell AM QC is the Executive Director of the Castan Centre for Human Rights Law, Commissioner for the Yoo-rrook Justice Commission, and Co-Chair of the Steering Committee of the National Mental Health Commission National Stigma and Discrimination Reduction Strategy. Among his many accomplishments, as Justice of the Supreme Court of Victoria and President of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Professor Bell has presided over some of Victoria’s most important human rights judgements, including Patrick’s Case and the 2017 PBU & NJE case on electroconvulsive treatment. Today we spoke about law, the role of judges in directly or indirectly exercising oversight of systems and how taking a human rights based approach can lead to the best experiences of and outcomes from, the courts. [A note on language: there are diverse ways to understand and describe distress. Different terms are used in this podcast. We discuss in the episode, the need to acknowledge labelling and power in how terms like mental illness and mental health are used] Show notes Guardian Australia pieces on Victoria’s mental health regulator: Story on under-enforcement: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/may/26/no-action-taken-against-victorian-mental-health-services-despite-more-than-12000-complaints?CMP=share_btn_tw Olivia’s story: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/may/29/you-dont-have-a-choice-victorias-mental-health-regulator-criticised-over-complaints-handling?CMP=share_btn_tw Cases discussed (explainers) Patrick's Case: https://www.hrlc.org.au/human-rights-case-summaries/p-j-b-v-melbourne-health-anor-patricks-case-2011-vsc-327-19-july-2011 PBU & NJE: https://www.legalaid.vic.gov.au/about-us/news/landmark-judgment-strengthens-patients-rights-in-compulsory-electroconvulsive-treatment-cases Matsoukatidou Case: https://www.hrlc.org.au/human-rights-case-summaries/2017/4/24/victorian-supreme-court-rules-that-courts-have-fair-hearing-and-equality-obligations-to-assist-self-represented-litigants  ...